mets

The Mets’ 11-Game Losing Streak: A Crisis in Queens

The New York Mets are mired in their longest losing streak in franchise history—11 straight games, dating back to early September. The latest chapter unfolded on Tuesday night at Wrigley Field, where the Cubs edged out a 7-5 victory in extra innings after a dramatic late-game collapse. It was a heartbreaker for a team that had rallied from a three-run deficit to tie the game in the ninth inning, only to see its lead vanish in the 10th on a solo homer by Cubs shortstop Dansby Swanson.

This loss marks the first time in modern MLB history that the Mets have dropped 11 consecutive games since 1999—and the first time ever against the Chicago Cubs in such a prolonged skid. The defeat extends a season that began with promise but has devolved into one of frustration and mounting questions about roster construction, pitching depth, and managerial decisions.

Recent Developments: How We Got Here

The Mets entered Tuesday’s series finale with momentum after two wins over the Cubs earlier in the series, fueled by strong performances from starters Jose Quintana and Kodai Senga. But the bullpen—already under scrutiny—couldn’t hold a 3–2 lead heading into the eighth inning. After closer Edwin Díaz blew his second save of the month, rookie reliever Griffin Grippa gave up the go-ahead run in the bottom of the ninth when Ian Happ hit a clutch two-run double off Mets setup man Adam Ottavino.

In the extra frame, with the score tied 5–5, Cubs starter Jameson Taillon—who had been pulled after six solid innings—was surprisingly brought back onto the mound despite having thrown just 87 pitches. He promptly gave up a ground-rule double to Pete Alonso before surrendering the decisive single to Michael Busch. The move drew immediate criticism from analysts and fans alike.

“It’s baffling why you’d take a starting pitcher out in the seventh with a lead and then bring him back in the 10th,” said former MLB manager Joe Torre on MLB Network. “That’s not how you win ballgames.”

Head coach Carlos Mendoza defended the decision afterward, citing Taillon’s efficiency and confidence. “He felt good, he wanted to pitch, and we trusted him,” Mendoza said during his postgame press conference. “But credit to the Cubs—they made us pay.”

Historical Context: When Did the Mets Last Struggle Like This?

While the current 11-game slide is unprecedented against any opponent, the Mets have experienced similar droughts before—just not this deep or this recent. In 1962, the inaugural Mets team lost 12 straight games en route to finishing last in the National League. More recently, in 2021, the Mets dropped nine in a row while rebuilding around young talent like Pete Alonso and Brandon Nimmo.

However, what sets this year apart is not just the length of the streak—but the timing. With just two weeks left in the regular season and the wild card race heating up, every game matters. The Mets currently sit 4.5 games behind the Atlanta Braves in the NL East and trail the Miami Marlins by 3.5 games for the final wild card spot.

Historically, teams that lose 11 straight games in late September rarely recover enough to make the playoffs. Only five franchises in MLB history have overcome an 11-game losing streak to reach the postseason: the 1985 Detroit Tigers, 1997 Cleveland Indians, 2007 Boston Red Sox, 2011 St. Louis Cardinals, and 2020 Tampa Bay Rays.

“You can’t win your way out of a slump like this,” said ESPN analyst Buster Olney. “At some point, you have to fix the underlying issues—whether it’s lineup balance, defensive alignment, or bullpen usage.”

Roster Concerns: Where Are the Problems Hanging?

A closer look at the numbers reveals several red flags:

• Bullpen ERA: 6.83 over the last 10 games
• Starting Rotation: Only two starters (Quintana and Senga) have posted quality starts in the past week
• Offensive Production: The Mets have scored just four runs total in their last three losses
• Defensive Errors: Five miscues in the last five games, including critical misplays by third baseman Jeff McNeil

Perhaps most troubling is the performance of veteran slugger Pete Alonso, who has gone 2-for-28 (.071 average) during the streak with eight strikeouts. His struggles at the plate come as the team desperately needs him to produce in high-leverage situations.

Meanwhile, manager Carlos Mendoza continues to rotate relievers without establishing a clear hierarchy. Ottavino, once considered one of baseball’s elite setup men, has allowed 11 earned runs in his last 12 appearances. Rookie right-hander Reed Garrett, acquired in a midseason trade, has yet to record an out in his brief stint with the big league club.

Immediate Impact: What Does This Mean for the Playoff Picture?

With only 14 games remaining, the Mets’ odds of making the postseason have plummeted. According to FanGraphs’ current projections, they now hold just a 19% chance of reaching the playoffs—down from 68% at the start of September.

The ripple effects extend beyond the standings. Ticket sales for remaining home games have dipped slightly, though demand remains high thanks to the team’s loyal fanbase. Local businesses near Citi Field report mixed results: while die-hard supporters still attend, casual fans appear hesitant to shell out $50+ for a game where the outcome feels increasingly inevitable.

“People love the Mets, but they also want hope,” said Maria Lopez, owner of a hot dog stand outside the stadium. “When you see guys like Ottavino walking off the field with his head down… it’s tough to keep selling peanuts.”

Internally, the organization faces pressure to make changes—not just in strategy, but possibly in personnel. General Manager Billy Eppler, who took over in June, has maintained a hands-off approach, emphasizing patience with young players. But whispers of potential trades—particularly for a reliable left-handed reliever or an offensive upgrade at first base—are growing louder within the industry.

Looking Ahead: Can the Mets Bounce Back?

Despite the bleak outlook, there’s still room for optimism. The Mets’ core—Alonso, Francisco Lindor, Senga, and Quintana—remains among the most talented in baseball. If they can stabilize their pitching and regain confidence in their bats, a late surge isn’t impossible.

Upcoming matchups could be pivotal. The Mets host the Philadelphia Phillies next week, a team fighting for its own playoff life. Sweeping that series would inject much-needed energy into the clubhouse and shift momentum decisively back toward contention.

Additionally, injuries may provide opportunities. Star shortstop Francisco Lindor is nursing a strained calf but expects to return soon. Third baseman Mark Vientos, who has been tearing up Triple-A Syracuse, might get another call-up if the offense fails to respond.

“We’ve been better than our record shows,” said catcher Francisco Alvarez after Tuesday’s loss. “We know what we’re capable of. It’s just a matter of putting it all together.”

Final Thoughts: A Season at a Crossroads

The Mets’ 11-game losing streak is more than a statistical anomaly—it’s a symptom of deeper organizational challenges. While individual performances have faltered and management decisions drawn fire, the bigger issue may lie in the lack of cohesion between pitching staff and hitting corps.

Baseball is a sport of cycles, and even the best teams endure slumps. But with the calendar ticking toward October, the Mets must find answers quickly. Whether through internal adjustments or external moves, the choices made in the coming days will define not just this season—but the direction of the franchise for years to come.

For now, fans in Queens can only watch, wait, and hope that the magic returns before it’s too late.