todd monken

The Cleveland Browns Head Coaching Search: Examining the Finalists Including Todd Monken

The NFL head coaching carousel is one of the most scrutinized processes in professional sports. For the Cleveland Browns, a franchise with a complex history and a passionate fanbase, the decision to hire a head coach can define the trajectory of the organization for years. As the Browns narrow down their search for a new leader, the process has zeroed in on a select group of finalists. Among the names generating significant buzz is veteran offensive strategist Todd Monken, alongside other notable candidates like Jim Schwartz and Nate Scheelhaase.

This article breaks down the current state of the Cleveland Browns' head coaching search, providing verified updates, contextual background on the candidates, and an analysis of what these decisions mean for the future of the franchise.

The Current Landscape: A Narrowing Field

The Cleveland Browns have been methodical in their search for a new head coach, casting a wide net initially but quickly moving to identify top-tier talent. According to verified reports from the Cleveland Browns and major sports outlets, the search has evolved significantly over the past few weeks.

Verified Updates and Timeline

The most recent developments indicate that the Browns are moving into the final stages of their interview process. The following points outline the key, verified events:

• Nate Scheelhaase’s Second Interview: The Cleveland Browns officially confirmed that they completed a second head coach interview with Nate Scheelhaase, the pass game coordinator for the Los Angeles Rams. This is a significant step, as second interviews are typically reserved for candidates who are strong contenders for the position. The team’s official website noted the completion of this interview, signaling serious interest in the up-and-coming coach.
• The Finalist Trio: A report from Cleveland.com indicates that the Browns are deliberating on three primary head coach finalists: Nate Scheelhaase, Jim Schwartz, and Todd Monken. This report suggests that the organization has narrowed its focus to these three individuals, each bringing a distinct style and level of experience to the table.
• Grant Udinski Withdraws: In a related development, ESPN reported that Jacksonville Jaguars offensive coordinator Grant Udinski withdrew from consideration for the Browns' head coaching job. Sources indicated that Udinski is now focusing his attention on the offensive coordinator vacancy with the Buffalo Bills. This withdrawal further clarifies the field for the Browns, leaving the primary focus on the remaining finalists.

It is important to note that while Anthony Lynn was mentioned in some initial reports, the most recent verified information from Cleveland.com highlights the trio of Scheelhaase, Schwartz, and Monken as the main subjects of deliberation.

Contextual Background: The Candidates

To understand why the Browns are considering these specific individuals, it is essential to look at their backgrounds and what they bring to the NFL's oldest franchise.

Todd Monken: The Offensive Innovator

Todd Monken is a name well-known to football fans, particularly those who follow college football and the NFL's offensive evolution. Currently serving as the offensive coordinator and quarterbacks coach for the Georgia Bulldogs, Monken has a reputation as a creative offensive mind.

• Experience: Monken’s coaching resume is extensive. He served as the head coach at Southern Mississippi and has held various offensive coordinator roles in both the NFL (Tampa Bay Buccaneers, Cleveland Browns in 2019) and college football.
• Philosophy: Monken is known for a pass-heavy, aggressive offensive scheme. His time at Georgia has been marked by high-powered offenses and back-to-back National Championships. His ability to develop quarterbacks and design complex passing concepts makes him an attractive candidate for a team looking to revitalize its offense.
• Connection to Cleveland: Monken previously served as the offensive coordinator for the Browns in 2019 under Freddie Kitchens. While that season was turbulent for the team, Monken’s work with quarterback Baker Mayfield was viewed by many analysts as a positive influence on the young signal-caller's development.

Jim Schwartz: The Defensive Veteran

Jim Schwartz represents the polar opposite of Monken in terms of coaching focus. A former head coach of the Detroit Lions, Schwartz is currently the defensive coordinator for the Cleveland Browns, a role in which he has excelled.

• Experience: Schwartz has decades of experience in the NFL, including a stint as the head coach of the Lions (2009-2013) and a successful run as the defensive coordinator for the Philadelphia Eagles, culminating in a Super Bowl LII victory.
• Philosophy: Schwartz is known for an aggressive, attacking 4-3 defense that prioritizes generating pressure on the quarterback. Under his leadership in 2023, the Browns' defense ranked among the league's best, showcasing his ability to maximize talent.
• Internal Promotion: Promoting Schwartz to head coach would be a popular move among players who respect his leadership and tactical acumen. It would also provide continuity for a defense that performed at an elite level.

Nate Scheelhaase: The Rising Star

Nate Scheelhaase is the wildcard in this group. As a younger coach, he represents the new wave of NFL coaching talent that has emerged from successful college programs and NFL coaching trees.

• Experience: Scheelhaase spent several years on the coaching staff at Iowa State before joining Sean McVay’s staff with the Los Angeles Rams. As the pass game coordinator, he has played a role in the development of the Rams' high-octane offense.
• Philosophy: Working under McVay has equipped Scheelhaase with knowledge of the modern, motion-heavy offensive schemes that have taken the NFL by storm.
• The Appeal: Scheelhaase is viewed as a high-upside candidate. While he lacks the head coaching experience of Schwartz or the extensive coordinator resume of Monken, his energy and knowledge of current offensive trends make him a compelling option for a franchise looking for a long-term solution.

Immediate Effects: What This Search Means for the Browns

The Browns' head coaching search is not just about filling a vacancy; it is about defining the team's identity for the next several years. The choice between Monken, Schwartz, and Scheelhaase represents three distinct paths.

Impact on Roster Construction

The head coach’s background heavily influences roster decisions. * If Todd Monken is hired: The Browns would likely prioritize adding dynamic playmakers at wide receiver and tight end to fit a vertical passing attack. The offensive line would need to be adept at pass protection. * If Jim Schwartz is promoted: The focus shifts to the defensive side of the ball. The team might look to add pass rushers and versatile defensive backs to maintain their elite status. * If Nate Scheelhaase is hired: The team would likely look to modernize the offense with younger personnel and focus on athleticism and versatility.

Locker Room Dynamics

The current roster has reportedly expressed a strong preference for Jim Schwartz, whom they view as a "player's coach." Hiring an external candidate like Monken or Scheelhaase would require a transition period to establish new authority and culture. Conversely, promoting Schwartz ensures immediate buy-in from the locker room.

Analyzing the Strategy: Why These Candidates?

The Browns' decision to focus on these three specific finalists reveals a lot about the organization's internal thinking.

The Offensive vs. Defensive Balance The inclusion of Todd Monken and Nate Scheelhaase highlights the Browns' recognition that offensive innovation is critical in the modern NFL. With the AFC North featuring high-powered offenses like the Baltimore Ravens and Cincinnati Bengals, the Browns understand the need to keep pace.

However, the presence of Jim Schwartz on the list suggests that the organization values the stability and dominance he has brought to the defense. It is a classic dilemma: do you hire an offensive mind to build around your quarterback, or do you promote a defensive mastermind who has already proven he can win games?

The "New" vs. "Experienced" Factor * Todd Monken offers a blend of NFL and college experience. His time in the college game keeps him connected to the evolving trends of younger players entering the league. * Nate Scheelhaase represents the cutting edge of coaching talent. The "Sean McVay tree" has produced several successful head coaches, and Scheelhaase is the next potential branch. * Jim Schwartz offers proven success. He has been a head coach before and knows the rigors of managing an NFL team. His recent success with the Browns' defense minimizes the risk associated with his hiring.

Future Outlook: Potential Outcomes and Risks

As the Browns move closer to a final decision, several potential scenarios and their associated risks come into play.

Scenario 1: Hiring Todd Monken

Potential Outcome: The Browns' offense becomes one of the most explosive in the league. Monken’s scheme opens up the field, creating mismatches and high-scoring games. Risks: Monken’s previous stint in Cleveland ended poorly, and he has a reputation for an aggressive style that